First anal

I'm married and have had a bad sex life with my wife for a long time. I am 50 and so is a guy i met on Craigslist before the personals were done away with. I had exchanged blowjobs with a guy across town from me over a 6 month period. It had evolved into him licking my ass and me letting him cum in my mouth and me cumming in his but I wanted more. I went to his house around midnight one night and we went back to the bedroom. He crawled up on his bed and I crawled between his legs and sucked him. Licking his balls and trying my best to deepthroat him. He told me to get on all fours and started licking my ass. I loved that part and it almost always makes me cum. He stopped and said "I want sucked again" so I eagerly went back to sucking his cock. After 5 minutes of sucking and me tasting precum he told me to bend over again and he licked my ass more and slid a finger into me. It wasn't uncomfortable or pleasurable. It was just pressure. He then put his cock up to my hole and I pushed back. He said "You really want fucked, don't you?" I said yes. I want to try it. He lived up his 6" cock and held it for me to push back on. I relaxed and pushed it into my ass. Slowly until he was all the way in. He held it there for a few seconds then slowly started pulling out then back in. He picked up the pace and I heard his balls slapping mine as he got harder. I reached back and spread my cheeks so he could see his cock going in and out of me as that is what I would want to see. He must have fucked me for 10 minutes in that position then wanted to be on top. I rolled onto my back and he continued fucking me with my legs on his shoulders. He was really fucking me hard and fast. After about 10 minutes in that position he still hadn't cum. He pulled out and rolled over. He started masturbating and I was so hot I started sucking on his balls as he beat off. When he was ready to cum he asked me "Do you want It?" Without hesitation I sucked his cock to finish him off without even thinking that it was ass to mouth. I swallowed his cum as it shot down my throat. He then sucked me off to finish me. I wanted him to cum inside me but maybe next time. I've also told him I want throat fucked. I'd like to know what people do now since Craigslist doesn't do the personals anymore.